Thursday, November 8, 2012

Is Fate the Enemy?

In class, Dr. Schuler asked if there was an enemy in this story. I heard lots of different answers, but in my opinion fate is the real enemy. In ancient Greece, not even the Gods could free you of your fate, so if Oedipus' parents had not abandoned him how would his fate be different? Is his fate ultimatley to be abandoned by his parents, therefore it sets a stage for him to kill them, or would his fate be different if they had not abandoned him. I kind of believe that because his parents abandoned him, his fate was their punishment. They tried to change fate so they were ultimately punished, but due to his guilt so was oedipus. All in all, fate is playing dirty, no matter what happens Oedipus is dealt a bad hand by fate. even if his mother did not commit suicide nor did he kill her, he would still be miserable due to that fact he laid with his mother. I do not believe he would be able to just ignore it and proceed with his life, but how could anyone that had any sense of morals. I don't want to say his mother deserved what happened, but once she found out that she had married her son, she should have told him. That's just my opinion, Fate seems to be the ultimate enemy, but his mother is no angel either. P.S. I commented on Amanda's Ignorance Is Not Bliss

2 comments:

  1. I believe you make a great point. Fate really does seem to be working against Oedipus. There is no way around the prophecy for Oedipus, or so it seems. Perhaps if they had not tried to circumvent Fate, Fate would have been a little kinder. But there's no way of knowing, so identifying Fate as the Villain is a good call!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I tend to agree with you Jasmne. Oedipus was stuck, because regardless of what he did his fate was sealed., making fate stand out as the true "bad guy." However, Megahan I don't know that a "would have been kinder" scenario is even possible, because the fates, ironically, are set because of his running from them. Not running would have changed his fate,meaning that an attempt to circumvent fate was a part of fate in itself.

    ReplyDelete